Stepbrother Desire (Erotica)

“Someone called the cops and that’s where it ended. They said we should have filed a police report last time, and they could have done more since it would have been a second incident, but they understood why we didn’t. They took the guy that sucker punched me away in the police cruiser, and said he would be charged with disturbing the peace, and public intoxication. It won’t get him anything more than a night in jail and a stiff fine. There were more than enough witnesses to corroborate what we said happened.”

There were a few long moments of silence as the sisters absorbed Mike and Emma’s story.

“After that, we came back home to decompress and try to salvage the evening. It seemed clear that the ‘click’ between Emma and Paul was still there, so we finished the movie and then took them home. I got tackle kissed, and Emma got a peck on the cheek.”

Danni finally began to relax and fell back into Mike, a single tear working its way down her cheek. He noticed she stifled a sniffle as she wiped at the tear.

“I’m okay, Danni, I promise,” Mike said.

Danni shook her head. “It’s not that you big dork,” she said, leaning into him. “Well, not entirely that. It’s just… well, I just hate myself over someone else having to pay for my own bad choices.”

Mike squeezed her gently and the other three sisters came over and hugged them both tightly, the five of them on the couch.

“SIX.”

“I told you once, and now I’m telling all of you. I’ll never let anyone do anything like that to any of you if I can prevent it. If I have to take a dozen ass whippings to protect each of you, I will, and gladly. Hey, you’re the only sisters I’ve got.”

They squeezed each other tighter and then Beth, Sarah, and Emma headed back to the other couch.

After a few minutes of quiet contemplation, Sarah finally broke the silence. “So how are we actually going to get Paul to sleep with Ashley?”

A few more long seconds of silence followed.Belonging to NôvelDrama.Org.

“Well, what I was thinking was something along the lines of our hot tub and a couple of blindfolds,” Emma said, “but Ashley is so damn yappy that he’d never be fooled that it wasn’t her. She’s also not even built remotely the same as I am.”

“You’re damn right about that,” Mike said under his breath, causing Danni to giggle softly on top of him. Then he had a thought, “What if we were to just ask him?”

“Nice idea, idiot.”

“What,” Emma blurted out, “like saying ‘Hey Paul, have you ever thought about and wanted to fuck your own sister?’ He’d either think you were just kidding, or deck you if he took offense.”

“Like I said before, Dick… Let the girl’s do the thinking. You just listen.”

“What about this,” Sarah said, having a sudden epiphany. “We could have some sort of party, maybe a costume party or something to celebrate the start of school. We invite some people we know, and have sort of an ‘Anything Goes’ room.”

The other sisters were already shaking their heads as Sarah trailed off.

“Well, you could do the hot tub idea if you were careful,” Danni said. “You guys would have to go a lot farther than just a kiss on the cheek though.”

The others glanced over at her, curious.

“Well, alcohol has to be involved, for the two dupes for sure. Once you get them a little bit silly, you get a little frisky, get everyone naked, blindfold those two and promise them a surprise. Then, you get him to have sex with Ashley, where she’s on her knees and he can’t tell that it isn’t you until it’s too late.”

They all thought for a few seconds, quietly running over that plan in their heads.

“Wait a second,” Mike said, having an uncharacteristic burst of intelligent thought. “We’ve been operating under the assumption that Paul is actually attracted to his sister, at least on some level. I mean, what if we go through with this, and he just fucking snaps. He could out us big time, call the cops on us. Who knows, he could claim we tried to make him rape his sister.”

The girls looked curiously at Mike for a few seconds, wondering how the heck he’d managed to come up with that surprisingly insightful idea.

“So we’re back to square one,” Beth said.

“Not necessarily,” Emma said. “What if we go with Mike’s original idea?”

Her sisters glanced at her incredulously. “The one you insulted him over?” Beth asked.

“Yes,” Emma answered simply. “Mike confesses what is going on with us. He tells his newest buddy Paul at a barbecue we can have, that he’s having strange desires for his sisters. Since Paul is a new friend, Mike isn’t losing anything if Paul freaks out and leaves, taking his sister with him. If he doesn’t freak out and understands, the least he would do is tell Mike he needs help. The best case scenario, he confesses that he has the same desires for his little space cadet sister that Mike does, for say, Danni or me. If Paul takes the bait, Mike admits a little more, like say, jerking off while watching us sunbathe.”

“They can’t sunbathe right now, the sun’s down.”

‘It wasn’t an offer, idiot. If you’re going to hang around for this, pay attention damn it.’

“Oh, I uh… then, never mind.”

‘Yeah…’

“That’s a great idea!” Beth agreed. “That way we don’t have to try and fool them and we can gauge how well it’s going to go at a party, and we can give Mike suggestions if we think it’s going well enough!”

Mike sighed, not wanting to tell his sisters that guys don’t usually have deep conversations like this after having just been introduced to each other, but pushed the urge down and shrugged it off inwardly.

“You think they’ll sunbathe tomorrow?”

‘Seriously, we’ve moved on now ass.’

“Well, it’s not absolutely perfect, but it’s the best plan we’ve got,” Sarah admitted. “Why don’t we go to the store in the morning and get something for the boys to cook. We can all wear our tiniest bikini’s and Paul can ‘catch’ Mike ogling at our goodies.”

“Ogling at our goodies?” Emma asked with a bemused smile on her face.